Welcome to Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant
Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant, nestled in picturesque City Island, Bronx, is a culinary gem revered by locals and visitors alike. Known for its vibrant atmosphere, Artie's offers a delightful menu filled with fresh seafood and hearty steaks, complemented by signature cocktails like the mango mint mojito. Diners rave about the welcoming service, with staff like Nicholas earning special mention for their attentiveness. The ambiance, enhanced by classic jazz and sunny windows, invites laughter and camaraderie. Whether indulging in mouthwatering lobster rolls or enjoying a robust meal with friends, Artie's promises an unforgettable dining experience punctuated by quality and warmth.
Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
Had my birthday dinner with my girlfriends there and had the best time!! The food was amazing, the drinks were delicious and a special shout out to Nicholas for being a fantastic waiter!! Thank you for taking such good care of me!
Artie's is the best Restaurant in City Island. The Food is always fresh, those Mango mint mojitos are smoken and the portions are perfect. The Vibe and decor are spot on for dinning. I love the service there they treat you like Family, ask for Nick tell him Jason Sent you, He will take good care of you and your people.
A number of locals and regulars recommended we not miss Artie’s while visiting City Island. Quite an institution with a great staff. We met the owner as we were seated. We sat in the bar room but at a window table with the sunlight streaming in. Bar was almost full at 630p on a Monday night. Excellent sign. Great classic jazz playing on the sound system. The room was comfortable and warm and full of laughter. Our server took our drinks order and recommended some items off the regular menu and the specials board. Of particular interest were the largest steamer clams I’d ever seen. They buy their seafood fresh 3 times a week. Nothing goes in the freezer. All our food was delicious. The complimentary bread butter and olive oil was exactly what we needed with those clams. By the time dinner was over we’d made friends with a local couple at the bar who got married at the Yacht Club here in the late 80s. So we moved over and had a few more rounds and listened to stories about the old days in this nice little town. I highly recommend this place for very good food, excellent service, strong drinks, unique ambience and overall a grand time.
One of my favorite places in city island. The lobster rolls are amazing! The deserts are delicious and the service is great.
Arties always delivers an amazing time. For Mother’s Day, they went above and beyond—flawless service (as always), incredible dishes, and cocktails that hit the spot. Easily one of the best restaurants around!
The food was really good. I did get the blackened steak with roasted potatoes and broccoli along with their version of seafood Alfredo. The customer service is superb. They were very welcoming and friendly. They do have free parking. If I have one complaint I would say that the potatoes was hard and the broccoli was bland but the customer service along with the Alfredo made me smile and that’s why I’m giving them five stars they had decent music.
My boyfriend and I came here for my mom's birthday today. She is very set on going to Sammy's fish box; it is her favorite City Island seafood restaurant, so I wanted to take her someplace different for a change. Needless to say this place did not disappoint, our server was a man named Nicholas. The experience itself was phenomenal; we got there a little after it opened so we were practically the first ones there almost. We sat in a section with window seats It was very cozy, the music was giving very comfortable and jam. The food was delicious, the appetizers were also delicious, the bread we kept requesting and the drinks were definitely slammin. My mom most definitely enjoyed herself here today and I think she has a new restaurant to add to her radar at City Island thankfully, I know I sure do. I definitely look forward to coming back here and I highly recommend this place to anybody looking for not only good food, good service, good drinks, good ambience but overall a good time.
Arties is always a great dining experience - much different from the traditional seafood shacks on City Island (which are also very enjoyable). Aside from amazing, fresh seafood, Arties serves up some expertly prepared steaks, chops and Italian specialties. Staff across the board is always friendly and on point. Definitely a repeat, go-to spot.
Location
-
394 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, United States Hotline: +1 718-885-9885
Welcome to Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant, a celebrated establishment nestled in the charming City Island of the Bronx, New York. With its prime location at 394 City Island Ave, Artie's has become a cornerstone of the community, renowned for its commitment to fresh seafood and hearty steak dishes that cater to both locals and visitors alike.
Upon entering Artie's, you are immediately enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere—an ambiance heightened by classic jazz melodies and the lively buzz of fellow diners. Here, the decor blends elegance with a homey comfort, making it an ideal setting for celebrations, casual outings, or a cozy dinner with friends. Patrons like Richele Rosenfeld have shared memorable experiences, celebrating special occasions with delicious food, exceptional drinks, and outstanding service from attentive staff members like Nicholas, who make every visit feel special.
Artie’s culinary philosophy revolves around freshness and quality. The establishment prides itself on sourcing its seafood fresh three times a week, ensuring that each dish, from succulent lobster rolls to the largest steamer clams, shines with ocean-fresh flavor. First-time visitors are often charmed by the exquisite mango mint mojitos, recommended by regulars like Jason Caraballo, who declares Artie's the best restaurant on City Island. Here, every dish tells a story—a fusion of rich flavors and culinary expertise that leaves diners raving.
The menu is an impressive showcase of what the sea has to offer, along with perfectly cooked steaks that satisfy heartier appetites. Customers like Jacqueline Lopez sing praises for the lobster rolls, highlighting the balance of taste and texture. Not to be overlooked are the desserts, which consistently garner acclaim for their deliciousness, making each meal at Artie's a well-rounded experience.
What truly sets Artie’s apart, however, is the sense of community it fosters. Many diners quickly become regulars, finding more than just a meal; they discover a welcoming space where laughter and conversation flow freely. David Hale Smith's experience at the bar illustrates this perfectly, sharing stories with locals and forging connections over exceptional food and service. Whether you’re there to celebrate a milestone or simply unwind with good company, Artie's ensures that you leave with a smile and a full heart.
This Mother’s Day, long-time patrons were treated with what Nadine Evans describes as “flawless service and incredible dishes.” It epitomizes why Artie's is not just a meal but an experience to savor. With every visit, expect outstanding hospitality, a diverse menu that caters to every palate, and a distinctive ambiance that makes you feel right at home.
If you’re looking for an exceptional dining experience, Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant awaits your visit. Whether it’s the fresh seafood, delightful cocktails, or the friendly staff, you'll find yourself returning for more. Make a reservation today, and see why so many have made Artie’s their favorite dining destination!
For reservations, call +1 718-885-9885 and immerse yourself in a culinary journey that you won’t soon forget.